A viral video purportedly recorded inside the locomotive cabin of the Kolkata Sairang Express shortly before its derailment near Guwahati has raised serious questions about a possible failure in the train's braking system. The footage, which appears to capture the final moments before the November 11 accident at Digaru Railway Station in Assam, shows the locomotive crew repeatedly attempting to stop the train using different braking mechanisms. However, the train appears to continue moving despite their efforts, eventually striking a dead end and coming to a halt with a heavy impact.
The video has triggered questions about the initial explanation provided by the Northeast Frontier Railway. Following the derailment, the railway zone stated that the loco pilot had failed to control the train, resulting in the accident. However, the footage has introduced another possibility: whether a technical malfunction prevented the crew from bringing the train to a stop.
The Northeast Frontier Railway has not issued an official statement specifically addressing the viral recording. Railway authorities have maintained that a detailed investigation is required before any conclusion can be reached about the circumstances surrounding the accident.
In the approximately 45 second recording, one of the locomotive crew members can be heard explaining that the available braking systems are not responding as expected. The crew member appears to refer to the Brake Pipe pressure, commonly known as BP pressure, while expressing concern that the reading is not decreasing.
The locomotive pilot also appears to indicate that several braking options have already been attempted, including the emergency brake, locomotive brake and A9 brake. Despite these efforts, the train does not appear to slow down sufficiently.
The crew member repeatedly expresses concern that none of the available mechanisms is working. The recording ends as the locomotive reaches a dead end, resulting in a sudden impact that brings the train to a halt.
The footage has attracted particular attention from experienced railway professionals because of an apparent discrepancy between the crew member's verbal explanation and the instrument readings visible inside the cabin.
Senior loco pilots who examined the recording have pointed out that the BP gauge appears to show pressure falling to nearly zero. This observation is significant because the crew member can be heard saying that the pressure is not decreasing.
According to one senior loco pilot, the discrepancy could have resulted from panic during an extremely stressful situation. However, the gauge reading raises a separate technical question about why the train apparently continued moving despite the pressure falling to such a low level.
In conventional railway braking systems, the Brake Pipe plays an essential role in controlling the brakes across the train. Changes in air pressure within the system help activate braking mechanisms. A substantial reduction in pressure is generally associated with brake application. However, interpreting the gauge reading alone cannot establish whether the entire braking system was functioning correctly.
The actual condition of the locomotive equipment, brake components, train formation and associated control systems will need to be examined before investigators can determine what happened.
Another detail attracting attention is the train's speed. According to the senior loco pilot who reviewed the footage, the speedometer appears to indicate that the train was travelling at approximately 40 kilometres per hour or possibly faster during the recording.
The train appears to continue moving towards the red signal despite the crew's attempts to apply the brakes. It eventually overshoots the signal and reaches the dead end before coming to a stop.
This sequence has raised concerns about whether the train experienced a braking problem, a failure in another control mechanism or a combination of technical and operational factors.
Railway safety experts have previously raised concerns about incidents involving trains failing to stop at designated signals. Such incidents can have serious consequences, particularly when trains enter restricted sections of track or approach locations where movement is prohibited.
However, the viral footage does not independently establish the cause of the Kolkata Sairang Express derailment. Its authenticity, complete recording and technical details must be verified by investigators before it can be treated as conclusive evidence.
The investigation will need to examine the locomotive's event recorder, speed records, brake pressure data, maintenance history and other available technical evidence. Investigators will also need to assess the actions taken by the locomotive crew and establish whether the braking equipment responded as expected.
The distinction between human error and equipment failure is particularly important in this case. The railway administration's initial explanation placed responsibility on the loco pilot's inability to control the train. The newly circulated footage, however, raises questions that cannot be resolved through the recording alone.
For now, the central issue remains unanswered: did the locomotive crew fail to control the train, or were their attempts to stop it undermined by a malfunctioning braking system? A thorough technical investigation will be necessary to establish the sequence of events and determine the actual cause of the derailment.

0 Comments